The Christmas Pickle Tradition: History, Meaning, and How to Play

One of the most delightful and unusual holiday traditions involves hiding a pickle-shaped Christmas ornament deep within the branches of your Christmas tree. This quirky custom has captured the hearts of families worldwide, transforming Christmas morning into an exciting treasure hunt. But what's the story behind the Christmas pickle ornament, and why has this peculiar tradition become so beloved?


The Christmas pickle tradition adds an extra layer of magic and anticipation to holiday celebrations. As a consistently best-selling ornament at Old World Christmas, the humble pickle has earned its place among angels, stars, and snowflakes as an essential Christmas decoration. Whether you're a longtime pickle enthusiast or discovering this tradition for the first time, the Christmas pickle brings smiles, laughter, and a touch of whimsy to the holiday season.


Let's explore the mysterious origins, symbolic meanings, and joyful customs surrounding the Christmas pickle ornament tradition.

What Is the Christmas Pickle Tradition?


The Christmas pickle tradition is a holiday game where a pickle-shaped ornament is hidden on the Christmas tree on Christmas Eve. On Christmas morning, family members—especially children—search the tree to find the well-camouflaged green pickle among the branches and other decorations.


The reward for finding the pickle varies by family:

  • An extra present or special gift

  • The privilege of opening the first present

  • Good luck for the coming year

  • A small prize or treat

  • The honor of being "pickle finder champion"

The tradition's charm lies in its simplicity and the excitement it generates, making Christmas morning even more magical for participants of all ages.


Pickle Ornament History: Where Did This Tradition Come From?


The German Connection Theory


The origins of the Christmas pickle tradition remain somewhat mysterious, with several compelling theories about how it began. The most popular story traces the tradition to Germany in the late 19th century.


According to this legend, a man named John Lower was imprisoned in Germany during difficult times. Given only a pickle as food, he survived his ordeal and was eventually freed. Lower became a pickle maker and created the first Christmas pickle ornament as a symbol of good luck, hope, and survival.


The Ancient Good Luck Symbol Theory


Another theory suggests the Christmas pickle represents an ancient symbol of good fortune. In this interpretation, pickles were believed to possess special powers in various cultures. The pickle ornament serves as a:

  • Symbol of hope during dark times

  • Reminder that light exists even in difficulty

  • Good luck charm for the year ahead

  • Representation of preservation and sustenance


The Truth About the Christmas Pickle Origin


Interestingly, while often attributed to German heritage, the Christmas pickle tradition is actually more popular in the United States than in Germany itself. Some historians suggest the tradition may have been created by German-American immigrants or even by ornament marketers in the early 20th century.


Regardless of its true origins, the Christmas pickle has evolved into a genuine and beloved tradition embraced by families worldwide.


Christmas Pickle Meaning and Symbolism


The pickle ornament carries rich symbolic significance:


Traditional Meanings:

  • Good luck and fortune - Finding the pickle brings blessings for the coming year

  • Hope and resilience - A reminder that better times follow hardship

  • Joy and playfulness - Represents the fun and lighthearted side of Christmas

  • Family togetherness - Creates shared memories and friendly competition

Modern Interpretations:

  • A quirky alternative to mainstream Christmas symbols

  • An inclusive tradition families can customize

  • A conversation starter about unique holiday customs

  • A collectible ornament category for enthusiasts


How to Start the Christmas Pickle Tradition


Setting Up Your Pickle Hunt


Step 1: Choose Your Pickle Ornament Select a traditional pickle ornament that blends naturally with your tree's foliage. The camouflage effect is part of the challenge!


Step 2: Hide the Pickle on Christmas Eve After children go to bed, hide the pickle ornament deep within the Christmas tree branches. Place it where it's visible but not obvious—somewhere that requires careful searching.


Step 3: Explain the Rules On Christmas morning, explain the tradition and let the hunt begin. Establish whether adults participate or if it's exclusively for children.


Step 4: Award the Winner Present the finder with their reward—whether it's an extra gift, good luck wishes, or special privileges for the day.


Pro Tips for Pickle Hiding

  • Vary the difficulty based on children's ages

  • Opt for a mini pickle ornament to challenge older children

  • Rotate the hider each year to keep it fresh

  • Set boundaries if your tree is very large

  • Take photos of successful finders for family memories

  • Create a tradition log tracking each year's winner


Tips for Building Your Pickle Collection


Many families collect multiple pickle ornaments, adding new varieties each year:

  • Start with the classic traditional pickle

  • Add specialty pickles as the tradition grows

  • Create a "pickle tree" with an entire collection

  • Gift pickle ornaments to friends starting the tradition

  • Collect limited edition or specialty pickle designs

Beyond the Ornament: Expanding the Pickle Tradition


The Christmas pickle has evolved beyond tree ornaments into a broader holiday phenomenon:


Pickle-Themed Decorations:

  • Christmas tree toppers

  • Holiday stockings with pickle designs

  • Wrapping paper featuring pickles

  • Pickle-themed greeting cards

  • Decorative pickle displays

Creative Variations:

  • Hide multiple pickles for different family members

  • Create a pickle scavenger hunt throughout the house

  • Award different prizes for different pickle varieties

  • Photograph the pickle in creative hiding spots

  • Start a "pickle journal" documenting each year's hiding spot


Why the Christmas Pickle Tradition Resonates


A Unique Addition to Holiday Celebrations


The Christmas pickle offers something special that traditional decorations don't:


For Families:

  • Creates anticipation beyond present opening

  • Involves everyone in an active tradition

  • Generates laughter and friendly competition

  • Provides a unique story to share

  • Builds memories year after year

For Children:

  • Adds excitement to Christmas morning

  • Encourages careful observation skills

  • Provides an achievable "win" during the holidays

  • Creates a tradition they can continue as adults

  • Offers bragging rights for the year

For Holiday Enthusiasts:

  • Represents quirky, off-beat Christmas charm

  • Provides collectible ornament variety

  • Offers conversation starter at gatherings

  • Connects to interesting historical mysteries

  • Celebrates the whimsical side of Christmas


Starting Your Family's Pickle Tradition This Year


Whether you believe in the pickle's powers of good luck or simply enjoy the fun of the hunt, this unique tradition brings smiles and brightness to the holiday season. The Christmas pickle tradition proves that sometimes the most memorable holiday customs are the most unexpected.


Ready to start your pickle tradition?


The Christmas pickle ornament transforms a simple tree decoration into an interactive game that spans generations. As one of Old World Christmas's best-selling ornaments, the pickle has earned its place as a beloved holiday staple alongside classic symbols like angels and stars.


This year, add a pickle ornament to your tree and create a new tradition that will have your family laughing, searching, and celebrating together for years to come.


Shop Christmas Pickle Ornaments


Old World Christmas offers a complete collection of hand-blown glass pickle ornaments, from traditional designs to sparkling specialty varieties. Each pickle ornament is crafted with attention to detail, ensuring your tradition begins with a quality heirloom piece.


Browse our complete pickle ornament collection and choose the perfect pickle to hide on your tree this Christmas.

Back to blog

Written by

Rachael Mitchell

Rachael Mitchell is a freelance writer based in Seattle, Washington, and has over 15 years of writing experience. She’d never be able to pick just one favorite ornament, but narrowed it down to the S’more and Tennis Ball. She always looks forward to s’mores in the summer with friends and family adding gourmet ingredients, and played 4 years of college tennis in the mid-west.

2 comments

I 💟❤️‍🔥💟❤️‍🔥 the pickle ornaments

Mom

Been doing the pickle for years. Love it.

Kevin

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.